Better treatment for the old and the dying

The British Liverpool Care Pathway was created in the 1990s as a guide to medical staff dealing with elderly people near to death.  It’s intention was to ensure people had a dignified and comfortable death.  Unfortunately, it has been used by some as a “tick-box” checklist , and in such a way that some patients have deprived of water and food.  This can come as no surprise.  Where human beings have a set of rules you can bet some will always cut corners, misunderstand, or get irritated and  impatient.

In response, new guidelines focus on providing personalised care, good communication and shared decision-making between staff, relatives and patients.  Staff are advised to undertake daily reviews of medication and hydration and checks to see if the patient has improved.  If there is any uncertainty about the best course of action, staff must seek help from more experienced colleagues.

Dare I say that with so many foreign nursing staff in Britain, both their English and their medical training can raise legitimate questions.  It’s wonderful that there are people who are dedicated to helping the old, sometime  grumpy, monosyllabic, ungrateful or even violent elderly people.  I have personal experience of the excruciating frustration one can feel, trying to do your best. But if  you are going to recruit inexpensive and inexperienced people,  you also need to train them properly to ensure they behave competently on a ward.

If you’ve ever been to an institution occupied by elderly people near death or with dementia you know all too well what I mean. Everybody, however old and gaga, deserves to be treated with skill, kindness and respect. Hidden away behind the blank faces and hopelessness are real people with senses of humour, wisdom and often extraordinary stories. Epicureans should try to be gentle, patient and kind. One day that old person could be you.

Old wives’ tales

Every culture has its old wives’ tales that are unsupported by science. American parents tell their children not to swim after eating, even though there’s no real evidence that this is dangerous. In South Korea, many older people fear that if you sleep with an electric fan in the room, you may never wake up.   The South Korean news media and scientists keep trying to debunk this notion, but it won’t go away.

In 2008, Chun Rim, a professor at the Department of Nuclear and Quantum Engineering at the Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, decided to actually test the hypothesis. He used his 11-year-old daughter, because no one else would volunteer.

“Every five minutes I checked her body temperature, blood pressure, and also the temperature of her hand,” he says.  She survived the night. Her vitals barely changed. And now, the whole family sleeps with fans blowing on them.   But seven years later, it doesn’t seem to have done much to make this persistent belief blow away.    ( 2015 NPR website)

This illustrates the comfort that human beings derive from weird beliefs of all sorts.  You can do surveys, studies, scientific analyses and so on, but a fixed belief dies hard.  I personally do not believe that walking under a ladder with a man with a pot of paint in his hand above me either brings bad luck or guarantees that I get splattered with paint.  But I very deliberately walk beneath the ladder to prove to myself that I am grown up and rational. (This latter claim is hotly disputed by my wife).

Most of these beliefs are harmless, but some are not.  The idea that if you kill yourself and others for the love of Allah you are rewarded in heaven with 72 young virgins is one of the silliest beliefs, even if it is one of the most stellar marketing claims ever for a religion (and for anything else I can think of, for that matter).  The actual translation seems to be controversial.  Some translate it as “companions of the same age”.   The number of virgins is not mentioned in the texts, and in any case many would settle for fewer than 72 anyway.  But the translation and the number of virgins doesn’t matter.  The myth persists and is the probable cause of countless useless deaths.

Vested interests are on trial, not capitalism

To the Financial Times:

Sir,  Sebastian Mallaby’s spirited defence of capitalism (“Shortsighted complaints about short-term capitalism”, August 6) highlights one of the main difficulties facing the global economy: how to recapture the dynamism of markets without being at their mercy. The issue of under-regulation is perhaps best seen in the financial markets, where, contrary to Mr Mallaby’s argument, the actions to maximise share prices are not the antidotes to inefficient markets, but rather reveal the dominance of short-term greediness and corporate myopia.

Very few CEOs see themselves remaining at corporations for a lifetime; hence, what happens in the future concerns them less than their bonus today. The logical antidote to short-termism should of course be corporate boards of directors; however, governance of boards remains flawed and CEOs can use current shareholder returns as a convenience to pursue self-serving strategies

The argument that advanced economies are crisis prone because of excessive corporate debt is wrong and the corollary view that increases in equity values provide a needed stabilisation function to capital markets is unproven. One does not have to share the views of radical economists to see the flaws in financial markets. Academic notables, such as professors Robert Shiller and Joseph Stiglitz, have amply demonstrated how markets misbehave, and the costs that societies bear for this malfeasance.

Even taking politicians such as Hillary Clinton out of the equation leaves us with many mainstream observers wondering what has gone wrong in the current version of capitalism that puts the profits of manipulated markets in the pockets of financiers and the risks of failing markets on the shoulders of the citizenry. Outright corporate tax avoidance, customised tax expenditures and underpriced bailouts are prevalent in corporate America. The solution starts with rigorous supervision, regulation and enforcement of market misbehaviours. It is not capitalism that is on trial, but rather the way in which its oversight has been manipulated by vested interests.

Danny Leipziger,     Managing Director, Growth Dialogue and Professor of International Business,  George Washington University,   Washington, DC, US

He says it so much better than I do.

 

Major US university drops SATs

George Washington University in Washington, D.C. has recently announced that it will no longer require applicants to take the SAT or ACT as entrance exams. The university has concluded that reliance on these tests was excluding some high-achieving students who simply don’t test well, and low-income, minority students who don’t bother to apply because their scores are too low.

GWU will still require pre-med and home-schooled students, as well as athletes, to submit test scores, but, like many of the more than 800 other four-year colleges and universities that were already test-optional, it hopes its admissions criteria will now capture a more diverse pool of students.

Some research has found that it isn’t  clear whether performance on those tests is a reliable predictor of future academic success, and that a student’s high school academic record (their GPS and the rigor of the courses taken), is a far better predictor of college success than the SAT or ACT.

Critics of the SAT and ACT have long argued that these tests are nothing more than filters that help institutions deal with large numbers of applicants.  ( A heavily edited version of an article from NPR, July 2025).

Sounds sensible to me.  I think more credence should be given to personal assessments by the high school as as to the academic capabilities of the student and the student’s own “selling” document (hand- written), explaining why he wants to go to university, what he feels he can get out of it and what he has achieved so far in his life.