Dragging the Queen into the Brexit farce?

Posted by on

Senior members of the United Kingdom’s ruling Conservative party are so concerned about the country leaving the European Union without a deal that they are planning to go over the head of the new Prime Minister and appeal directly to the Queen.

Fears are growing among politicians that if and when Boris Johnson becomes PM next week, he could take the UK out of the European Union without any sort of deal later this year, resulting in a drop of 5% in the UK stock market, a 10% drop in the pound  and a fall of 2% in GDP by the end of 2020. One group of senior Conservatives are planning to go straight to the monarch.
Queen Elizabeth has built her reputation by remaining studiously impartial, and won’t want any part of the move. But the politicians could theoretically force her to enter the controversy by using an arcane and rarely used parliamentary procedure called the “humble address.”. This is effectively a direct call from parliament to the palace, bypassing Downing Street. This rebel group plans to use it to ask the Queen to exercise her right as head of state to travel to the next EU summit and ask for a Brexit delay.
But that would put the Queen in an awkward position; her likely response would be to bounce it straight back to the government, according to leading constitutional experts. Professor Vernon Bogdanor of King’s College London told CNN: “The safest rule for the Queen is always to take the advice of her ministers. That keeps her safe from criticism.”
Meanwhile Robert Hazell, professor of government and constitution at University College London, says the strategy is a complete non-starter.  “MPs might use a motion for a humble address to indicate their strong opposition to No Deal, or strong opposition to Parliament being prorogued; but the idea of the Queen attending the EU summit is absurd,” Hazell told CNN.  “Summit meetings are for heads of government, not heads of state: Denmark will be represented by their PM, not their Queen, and ditto all the other monarchies in the EU (of which there are six, in addition to the UK),” he added.
This latest twist in the UK’s Brexit saga shows how concerned some politicians are about Johnson’s premiership, even within his own party. On Thursday lawmakers voted to make it more difficult for the new leader to suspend parliament and impose a no-deal Brexit.  (reported last night by CNN)
My comment: involving the Queen, even if she concurred, is a total no-no, a further disastrous mis-step, quite possibly resulting in calls for the abolition of the monarchy by Brexit extremists.  You simply do not do this!  (although I ‘m guessing that the Queen must be as appalled as other thoughtful people at the prospect of Boris Johnson and mess being created). Curiously, talking to (necessarily very few) younger people, they don’t seem very engaged or concerned.  It is they that will have to live with this and take the consequences.  A further little sign of how turned off even educated people are.

One Comment

  1. The mood in Britain is anxious. Faced with the cliff-edge of no deal, the stakes have ever been higher. In such an atmosphere, both Leave and Remain supporters are capable of irrationality. Unfortunately, a compromise Brexit, which accounts for both the referendum result and the narrowness of it, is the least likely scenario.

    Reply to this comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.